Industry

What are Fixer-Uppers?

Updated 2026-06-02

In the vacation rental industry, a fixer-upper is a property needing substantial repairs, cosmetic updates, or structural changes to become a habitable and appealing short-term rental. Investors purchase these properties at a lower price point, anticipating that the renovation costs plus the purchase price will be less than the market value of a comparable, move-in-ready property.

The primary goal is to build equity and generate rental income or achieve a higher resale price.

Join the Lodgify newsletter

Once a month, get free templates, expert tips for hosts, industry news, webinar invitations, and more.

How it works

An investor first identifies a property with good potential in a desirable rental market, often one that is structurally sound but cosmetically outdated or in disrepair. After the purchase, they undertake renovations, which can range from simple updates like painting to major overhauls such as kitchen remodels or structural additions.

The work may be performed by the investor to build 'sweat equity' or by hiring professional contractors. Once the renovation is complete, the property is furnished, photographed, and listed as a vacation rental.

Why it matters

Fixer-uppers can offer a strategic entry point into desirable, high-cost rental markets by allowing investors to purchase a property below the average market rate. This strategy can result in higher equity and potentially greater ROI compared to buying a turnkey property.

Renovating a property also allows owners to customize the layout, design, and amenities specifically for their target guest, creating a unique and highly marketable vacation rental that can command higher rates and occupancy.

Examples

  • An investor buys an outdated 1970s cabin near a national park for a low price, completely modernizes the interior, adds a hot tub, and markets it as a retro-chic mountain getaway.
  • A couple purchases a small, neglected beachfront cottage, performs extensive storm-proofing and cosmetic renovations, and re-lists it as a premium honeymoon suite with direct beach access.
  • A property manager acquires a foreclosed home with a dated kitchen and bathrooms in a popular tourist city, renovates these key areas, and turns it into a high-end urban rental for business and leisure travelers.
  • An entrepreneur buys a large, dilapidated farmhouse, converting the main house into a rental while planning future conversions for the outbuildings to create a multi-property vacation complex.

Frequently asked questions

What is 'sweat equity' in the context of a fixer-upper?+
Sweat equity refers to the non-financial value an investor adds to a property by performing the renovation work themselves instead of hiring professionals. This can significantly reduce labor costs and increase the overall return on investment, but it requires the investor to have the necessary skills, tools, and time.
Are fixer-uppers a good investment for first-time vacation rental owners?+
They can be, but they carry higher risks. First-time investors should have a significant cash reserve for unexpected repair costs, a reliable team of contractors if not doing the work themselves, and a thorough understanding of local zoning and building codes. A property requiring only cosmetic updates is often a safer start than one needing major structural work.
How do I estimate the cost of renovating a fixer-upper?+
A common guideline is to pay no more than 70% of the property's After Repair Value (ARV) minus the estimated repair costs. It is crucial to get detailed quotes from multiple licensed contractors for all planned work and add a contingency fund of 15-20% to the budget to cover unforeseen expenses that frequently arise during renovations.
Keep reading

Related terms

Stay in the loop

Join the Lodgify newsletter.

Once a month, get free templates, expert tips for hosts, industry news, webinar invitations, and more — straight to your inbox.

One email a month. Unsubscribe anytime.